Will Yelp Remove A False Review?
Yelp states on their website that they will not remove a suspected false review unless it violates some other term. Yelp allows lies, and even quasi-libelous reviews, as long as racial slurs are not included in the review and the review is not hearsay.
If someone posts a false review, here is Yelp's advice for dealing with the problem: "We don't arbitrate disputes, so your best bet is to contact the reviewer or post a public response in order to clear up any misunderstandings." There may very well be cases where a business owner successfully has convinced Yelp to remove a false review, so I still say it is worth a try, even if the FAQs on their website seem to indicate there is no appeals process.
In order to confront your accuser:
- You have to create a business account and claim your listing, and
- "Yelp requires business account users to upload a real photo before messaging customers in order to make the message personal. Photos should clearly show your face (no sunglasses please) and not include too many people."
In other words, I can post a lie about your business anonymously, but to respond to my "review" you have to offer a picture clearly showing who you are. The 6th Amendment to the United States Constitution gives us the right to face our accusers but Yelp does not require people who post reviews to use a real name, picture, or even location in order to protect their identity. Just because a business is public does not necessarily mean its owners or employees want their own personal identities associated with their Yelp profile page.
What about corporations where no one person owns the business? Should the company pick a fall guy or a spokes model instead of the corporate logo? I suggest business owners use stock photos -- the people are pretty and reviewers in your home town won't be able to spot you at the mall and go off on you while your wife and kids are with you.
My biggest concern is that the ability to reply to a reviewer is not the same thing has having your name cleared, or the ability to control reviews -- or the ability to simply opt out and have your entire profile removed from Yelp. Even the CAN-SPAM Act of 2003 requires anyone sending out a newsletter to give people a chance to opt out.
People should not be forced to participate online in anything they do not want to participate in -- especially when it can damage their reputation!.
And yet ...
Reviewers Can Openly Accuse Businesses Of Anything They Want -- Even Of Committing Crimes
A review should be an assessment; the best are unbiased and simply explain why someone recommends or does not recommend a business. But those are rare, and, frankly, difficult for most people to write because our emotions do factor into what we say be they negative or positive. But many Yelp reviewers write more op-eds than reviews. Some even make accusations that, whether or not they are true, should not be said publicly unless you are prepared to back up those accusations in a court of law.
The law says "presumed innocent until proven guilty." Yelp practices seem to suggest a mentality of, "accuse someone and we will assume it is true and let it stand" (because most negative reviews are not filtered.) Unlike in the legal system, there really is no appeals process for Yelp decisions.
To publicly accuse someone falsely of a crime in such a way that it is likely to cause harm to reputation, is defamation, which is crime. In the case of false accusations posted on Yelp, because they are in writing, it is libel (also illegal). However, Yelp does not arbitrate and will not remove such posts, except, perhaps in rare occasions and only at its sole discretion.
If you put up a sign in your yard presenting criminal accusations as fact about your neighbor it is called libel. Do it on Yelp and it is called a review.
Here are a few examples of people who accuse others of specific crimes -- unfiltered reviews I easily found in random searches on November 16, 2012:
- "One of the drivers stole my wallet with all my identification and money. After paying for tip, I exited the car with my belongings and the driver went off. Sixty seconds later, I noticed the wallet was gone." Sophia L., New York
- Filly F., a California woman, has accused two hospitals, a doctor, and nursing home of medical neglect and malpractice, a dentist of insurance fraud, and a private psychologist of taking financial kickbacks from a school district."
- May Y. of Glendale, CA, accused a plastic surgeon in one review of not having good ethics, medical negligence, and malpractice.
But how many business owners being falsely accused have the time or inclination to sue reviewers? Libel is a hard thing to establish, and so business owners remain relatively powerless to fight back against false criminal or other undocumented allegations and accusations.