When talking straight income tax, the two candidate's tax cut plans compare as follows:
Under Obama's Tax Cut Plan:
Individuals and couples earning between $37,595 and $66,354 per year would see an average savings of $1,118 on their personal income taxes.
Under McCain's Tax Cut Plan:
The same wage earners who would receive a tax cut under Obama's plan would also receive a cut under McCain's. However, the average savings would be $793 less on McCain's plan or, an estimated average savings of $325 for those who would save an estimated $1,118 on Obama's plan.